§ 01Ideas

The thinking behind the method.

Two ideas from the research shape how we choose an approach to change and how we develop the leaders inside it. Each is set out here in full, with its figures and sources.

  1. § 02Matching the approach
  2. § 03Clones and tribes
§ 02Approach

Not every change should be run the same way.

Participation is our default, not our dogma. Research on change leadership distinguishes three approaches and argues that the situation should decide among them: how complex the system is, and how well the problem and its answer are understood.3

  1. 2.1

    Directed change

    A fixed goal, a tight process and a fast pace. The leader decides, explains, and holds people to it. It fits simpler, well-understood problems and real emergencies. Directive is not authoritarian: done well, it still listens and is open about costs and benefits.3

  2. 2.2

    Planned change

    A clear goal, with a flexible, participative plan built with the people involved. It fits complex systems where the answer is broadly known.3

  3. 2.3

    Iterative changing

    A loose direction, with goal and process worked out together by trying things and learning as you go. It fits problems where neither the problem nor the answer is yet clear.3,7

Fig. 1 Complexity, uncertainty and the approach that fits. Adapted from Kerber and Buono (2018, Fig. 1).

Large changes usually need all three at different moments, in a rhythm rather than a single choice.3 What damages trust is a mismatch, and worst of all, staged participation, where people are consulted on a decision already made.3 We say plainly which kind of moment it is.

Skip the rhythm figure
Fig. 2

One rhythm, for an organization that must become something new.

  1. Initiation · DirectedLeaders set the direction and explain why the change is needed.
  2. Exploration · IterativePeople try options together and learn what could work.
  3. Rollout · PlannedThe chosen design is planned and rolled out with the people involved.
  4. Final implementation · DirectedLeaders hold the course until the new way is in place.

Fig. 2 One illustrative rhythm, for an organization that must become something new. Adapted from Kerber and Buono (2018, Fig. 3); the phase descriptions are ours. Scroll the figure sideways to follow the four phases.

The evidence behind this framework comes from consulting cases and classroom discussion. We present it as a framework the research proposes, not as a proven model, and we use it to make our judgment explicit.3

§ 03New leaders

Why new leaders become copies of old ones.

Leaders are often promoted for technical skill and given no development. They then learn leadership from the team they join, consciously or not. Leadership Clone Theory describes this mimicry.2 In a healthy leadership team it can help. In a toxic one, a new leader with good instincts can lose them.2

Fig. 3 Clone imprinting. A new leader crosses from the staff group to the leadership team and takes on its pattern, and the gap between the groups widens. Drawn from the argument of Shufutinsky (2019).
  1. 3.1

    Cloning

    The new leader takes on the leadership team's behaviour, power distance and style.2

  2. 3.2

    Tribalism

    Groups bind tightly. Where staff and leaders are already at odds, a new leader is pressed to pick a side, and former colleagues may come to see them as a traitor.2

  3. 3.3

    Power over, or power with

    Power-over is authoritarian or coercive; power-with is developed jointly and is non-coercive. Either can reach a goal, but power used over people can deepen an "us versus them" split between leaders and staff.2

  4. 3.4

    The cost

    Hostility, distrust, conflict and stress, followed by absenteeism, turnover and lost performance.2

Fig. 4 Power over and power with. Original diagram after the distinction described in Shufutinsky (2019), drawing on Follett.

The remedy is not quick. It combines dialogue, use of self, leadership development and team building, with an outside party where needed. Better still is prevention: developing leaders before and as they are promoted, not after the damage.2

§ 04Contact

Tell us what needs to change.

Send a few lines about your organization and where things feel stuck. We will reply to arrange a first conversation.

Book a conversation